Commit graph

6 commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
igneum-labs
402c71bf68 Review round 4 (4 October 2026, afternoon): what is live. 1 fatal, 16 serious, 8 minor, 1 fixed; ledger X18 to X30, G12 to G14, F23, F24, M25 to M29, E16, E17, L9; fixes rows 104 to 116
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-10-04 18:05:28 +00:00
igneum-labs
035a63013e External review of the litepaper: response, 15 ledger entries, fix rows, open items, four-state rule, miner-app rules, phase-2 gate
docs/review/external-2026-10-03.md holds the reviewer's text verbatim and the
classification: 13 already answered, 15 new, 1 wrong. New ledger entries M22,
F19, F20, P16, P17, E12, E13, E14, E15, G11, X13, X14, X15, X16, X17 with
cross-references on M1, P1, E1, G6, X1, X5, F16. fud-fixes rows 89 to 103.
Open items O-3.15, O-3.16, O-5.9 to O-5.11, O-7.1, O-7.2, O-8.2, O-8.3,
O-X.1 to O-X.3 (count 73). Execution layer 2.4: included, executed, proven,
finalised. Phone app 4.1: net earnings after tariff, two incomes, failed jobs,
release state, isolation. journey.json phase-2 gate: fixed workload, end to
end, no growing backlog, three independent reproductions.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-10-03 22:29:41 +00:00
igneum-labs
31ccd2752b Review round 3: litepaper reorg bound and emission sentences, design 5.5 veto (F15, E10, P11)
Litepaper Finality: the reorg bound users rely on is the 12-hour finality depth in median time; Kaspa's one-hour merge depth is a merge limit, not a reorganisation bound; first-month sentence and "does not claim" item 4 say the same. Litepaper Speed: emission per block on a schedule keyed to difficulty-adjusted time, reds in the window paid, coins track blocks within the controller's accuracy.
Design 5.5 and D12: the native-execution veto is relative to the carrying block's own selected-parent chain; two-node reorg test added to 8.5.
Ledger P11, F15, E10 statuses and fixes rows 79, 82, 84 updated.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-10-03 20:46:40 +00:00
igneum-labs
09900b9432 Review round 3: spec rules for F15, F17, F14, P11, E9, E10, G9; ledger and fixes rows
The four public sentences (F18, P13, E11, L7 in site/litepaper.html and site/index.html) were swept into the concurrent commit cd604db; this commit carries the rest.

Spec 02: finality depth (43,200 DAA s, 12 h of median time) named as the reorg bound, merge depth as a merge limit only, simnet reorg test for gate 2; emission follows the code (365.25-day year, 63,115,200-s halving, 31.688 IGN per DAA second, reds inside the DAA window paid to the merger, E paid per block so coins are blocks times E).
Spec 03: W2 and Q1 denominated in past-median time, weight as a share of each 60-s bucket; W6 keys are free, weight is the only Sybil-resistant quantity; 3.8 and 3.9 point exchanges at the finality depth.
Spec 06: O-3.14, the finality simulation with the DAA in the loop under a pulsed rental (gate 3).
Spec 07: shard sortition draws by weight (blue blocks drawn uniformly from the window); proof-record validity is relative to the carrying block's own selected-parent chain; 1-key-versus-1,000-keys test.
Spec 08: release-key chain, rotation signed by the current key, revocation signed by the previous key, both published in a block; policy before the client ships.
Ledger: status lines for F18, P13, E11, L7, P11, F17, F14, M14, F15, E9, E10, G9; P8 cross-reference. Fixes: section 2.2 rows 75 to 88, with M15, M20 and P12 marked code, owner consensus engineer.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-10-03 20:44:40 +00:00
igneum-labs
95bdd48631 Spec: close F2, F3, P5, P8, C9, E7, G7, X6 by rule or decision (3 October 2026)
- 03-finality: Q2 participation from every vote seen in blocks (votes are
  block payload); 3.3.2 the eclipse case closed by the 56.7% floor with the
  sim v2 F2 numbers; 3.4.1 why aggregators cannot grind participation.
- 07-execution (new): EVM semantics on the DAG, shard sortition (8 provers,
  10 s, then open, no shard bond), bridges (none official, no bridged
  stablecoins at genesis, proof bridge with the consensus proof in phase two).
- 08-client-security (new): reproducible builds, release key in genesis and
  in hardware, no silent updates, consensus only by 90% signalling, notarised
  builds, official sources with the hash, seed confirmed before mining,
  hardware wallet, the permanent seed line.
- 00, 02, 05, README, 06: cross-references, O-2.8 removed, O-3.3, O-3.7,
  O-5.1, O-5.2, O-5.6 narrowed, O-8.1 added, counts kept at 60.
- Ledger: eight Status lines, status table, count table, overclaims 38, 40, 71.
- FUD fixes: rows 23, 26, 38, 62, 64, 66, 67, 70, 72, section 3 and 4.
- Site: bridge and stablecoin sentences no longer launch features; the seed
  line wherever the app appears.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-10-03 18:58:39 +00:00
igneum-labs
f0181b4ac2 FUD fixes: the ordered work list from the ledger, with exposure flags
Every open, conceded and answered-with-remainder entry of docs/fud-ledger.md
as one row: fix, owner, timing, and whether it exposes the team. The 78
overclaims checked against the live site text. What the 3 October decisions
close. The pre-public-repo scrub, in order, including the history rewrite.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-10-03 18:39:28 +00:00